Grankspoine

Monday, March 13, 2006

The laptop charioteers

As a new season of formula 1 has arrived in a blaze of high-decibel OTT graphics and superficial glitz all in inverse proportion to its sporting or entertainment value, I'm sure grand prix enthusiasts all look forward to a succession of Sunday afternoons filled with high-speed drama, exquisite displays of human skill and bravery, and of dizzying hard-fought close racing.

Well, at pretty much any time between the 1950s and 1980s they might, and with justification. But this is of course the early 21st century: grand prix enthusiasts have been replaced by 'Effwun fans' – a breed of largely under-25s who wear baseball caps, drink American-style beers straight from the bottle, and who think the words 'good/yes/alright/excellent/I understand' etc can all be replaced by the single word 'cool' (which they're too lazy to pronounce properly); and real racing cars have long been replaced by software-assisted four-wheeled PlayStation guided missiles which are so easy to drive that even a member of the public could safely conduct one round a (slow) lap after ten minutes' instruction.

What TV viewers will actually get each grand prix weekend is a commentary team whose idea of excitement is 'pit stop strategies' (in which 'overtaking' is something which takes place in the pits and against the clock, rather than on the track and against a human opponent), one and a half hours of shots of cars following each other around the track with little change in order because their over-reliance on aerodynamic downforce mitigates against getting close to a car ahead, and of course those pulse-racing shots of software engineers (also wearing baseball caps) sitting in their team garages and prodding away at laptop computers.

Nuvolari and Fangio would turn in their graves to see what was once a glorious human spectacle turned into such a pathetic nerd-fest.

The two men supposedly in charge of formula 1 are FIA boss Max Mosley, and head money-maker Bernie Ecclestone. Changes made to the regulations in the closed season (most notably a reduction in engine size and number of cylinders to 2.4-litre V8s) have shown that even a man of Mosley's unquestioned intelligence and ability is simply repainting the bridge on the Titanic as icy waters flood the compartments below him. The loss of TV audiences over the last three seasons shows that even the easily-pleased couch blobs are voting with their big fat thumbs on the remote.

Mosley said the engine reduction would cut costs and slow the cars down. Those responsible for having to design and build the new engines told him it would do neither. But 'leaders' never listen to engineers, so Mosley set his desires in stone and now we have new smaller engines. As a result, engine costs have rocketed, and in the weekend before the opening event of the season, Honda driver Anthony Davidson broke the lap record in Barcelona driving a new (smaller) V8-engined car.

Part of the problem is formula 1's unique nature. In almost every other sphere of motor sport (there are lots of these, by the way, although few F1 fans have heard of them), teams acquire the major components for their machines – chassis, engines, gearboxes etc – from a limited number of highly specialist manufacturers which supply all the teams in the same racing series. In formula 1, the teams design and build their own cars (in some cases also the engine/gearbox). This is bespoke racing engineering of the highest order, and so formula 1 has always been a championship for teams as well as drivers.

And the balance between human skill and technological skill has always been a finely balanced and fascinating part of the genre. Until now…

Because the last 10-12 years have seen formula 1 increasingly dominated by multinational car manufacturers, who pump hundreds of millions of dollars a year into 'their' teams to allow them to develop software technologies (traction control, semi-automatic gearboxes etc) intended merely to make their next generation of road cars safer and easier to drive: technologies, in other words, which have no role in any sphere of motor sport – least of all its self-declared 'pinnacle'.

This has long caused arguments among those who cared about formula 1, the argument put by the technology fans being "You can't just un-invent technology". But this outstanding piece of moronicity ignores the power of the rulemakers to ban something if they decide it to be outside the interests of 'the sport'. And this is the decision they now face: is formula 1 an entertainment arena glorifying human skill and high-speed bravery, or is it just a TV showcase for roadcar software systems?

If it's the latter, then let's drop the pretence and lose the drivers completely: their space in the cockpit can easily be replaced by the hydraulic servos and actuators necessary to control steering, throttle and brakes, all controlled remotely by someone strapped into an immersion rig in the garage. Tiny cameras on the car will give all necessary visual information to a head-mounted wraparound display. And since this is taking formula 1 closer to the computer game world it increasingly resembles, the operator will need no 'traditional' racing skills and is instead more likely to be a 12 year-old kid from Tokyo or Kidderminster, and will clearly also be far cheaper than a $12m-a-season real driver.

But if it's the former – a contest for humans – then let's make it a proper one and look to earlier eras to remind ourselves why it was we liked motor racing in the first place. Formula 1 cars don't have to be the fastest or most sophisticated racing cars: but they should be the most challenging and the most demanding, thereby attracting the best drivers and remaining the pinnacle of motor sport. I propose a car with characteristics of the 1950s grand prix and 1960s formula junior cars: something very small and light (say 450kg dry) with three-litre V12 engines producing 950bhp; all-metal brakes to increase braking distances and reintroduce outbraking; fully manual racing gearboxes to give control back to the driver; very small wings to limited aerodynamic downforce, and fully slick but narrow tyres. Oh – and no software onboard whatsoever.

Would this be a step backwards? Well, it would give cars with precise delicate handling, and with huge power compared to their limited grip. It would give cars which were enjoyable for the drivers, which were spectacular to watch…and would permit real on-track overtaking.

And the laptop prodders could go back to their data analysis companies. Remember where you read it first.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home