Please don't fret…
Writing in the Guardian's G2 section (28.03.06), Charles Shaar Murray delivered a piece on the 're-emergence of guitar solos in rock music' so dripping with clichés I can only assume he'd been re-reading some of his old NME pieces. The thrust of the piece is that now that drum machines and sequencers have had their day, everyone's buying guitars and trying to play like Jimi Hendrix.
But this isn't true.
Since at least the turn of the century, neo-guitar bands have been buying vintage guitars/basses (Gibsons, Gretsches, Rickenbackers) and amplifiers (Carlsboro, Vox, Marshall) in the hope that some of the old magic will rub off on them. But unfortunately it doesn't: simply buying vintage guitars to try and look cool is no substitute for taking the trouble to learn to play the things properly – the way their predecessors did over 30 years ago.
Many of the bands Murray writes about (Franz Ferdinand, Kaiser Chiefs, Arctic Monkeys) are fine songwriters, but none of them has the manual or mental dexterity necessary to allow their brains and fingers to take (occasional) flight. All visual evidence available to this blogger (ie TV) clearly shows the timid thinking and rigid fingers which will prevent these bands ever being more than journeymen strummers.
Still – that's probably just as well. There are parts of America where large pockets of guitar über-nerds believe it's still 1982 and that the world still waits to be rescued by spandex-clad axe heroes.
But this isn't true.
Since at least the turn of the century, neo-guitar bands have been buying vintage guitars/basses (Gibsons, Gretsches, Rickenbackers) and amplifiers (Carlsboro, Vox, Marshall) in the hope that some of the old magic will rub off on them. But unfortunately it doesn't: simply buying vintage guitars to try and look cool is no substitute for taking the trouble to learn to play the things properly – the way their predecessors did over 30 years ago.
Many of the bands Murray writes about (Franz Ferdinand, Kaiser Chiefs, Arctic Monkeys) are fine songwriters, but none of them has the manual or mental dexterity necessary to allow their brains and fingers to take (occasional) flight. All visual evidence available to this blogger (ie TV) clearly shows the timid thinking and rigid fingers which will prevent these bands ever being more than journeymen strummers.
Still – that's probably just as well. There are parts of America where large pockets of guitar über-nerds believe it's still 1982 and that the world still waits to be rescued by spandex-clad axe heroes.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home